The Mask Controversy in America

In the current landscape, the conflict between ideology and scientific guidance is becoming increasingly evident. The reality is clear: when ideology overshadows scientific consensus, everyone suffers.

Update 6/7/22: LEVEL has transitioned to a new platform. To explore this article and others, visit LEVELMAN.com.

If current trends persist, by November 1, the death toll from Covid-19 may surpass 224,000 in the U.S. This alarming prediction from the University of Washington's Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) reflects the ongoing rise in infections and hospitalizations, particularly in states like Texas, California, Arizona, and Florida. While no region is spared from the devastation caused by this global health crisis, the United States seems intent on leading the world in fatalities.

The most recent IHME projections have risen by 16,000, marking an increase of nearly 8%. However, there exists a straightforward solution to avert over 40,000 additional deaths: Americans must stop resisting scientific advice and start wearing masks.

According to the IHME, "If 95% of Americans wore masks each time they left their homes, infection rates would plummet, hospitalizations would decrease, and projected deaths would decline."

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) echoes this sentiment. Dr. Robert Redfield, the CDC director, stated, "If we could get everyone to wear a mask right now, I believe we could control this epidemic within four, six, or eight weeks."

However, the leadership problem stems from the top. My frustration is directed at those influencing the public’s perception. As I have reiterated, our collective fate was sealed the moment Donald Trump chose not to wear a mask.

On Monday, Surgeon General Jerome Adams appeared on Fox & Friends, urging viewers to adopt mask-wearing. He claimed, "This administration is now supportive of masks." While I generally have a fondness for those named Jerome, his use of "now" is concerning.

After months of pandemic challenges, this statement feels disingenuous—140,000 deaths too late. The administration’s refusal to act renders Adams' statements ineffective.

Recent interviews reveal Trump’s dismissive attitude toward scientific guidance. While he professes to believe in masks, his actions tell a different story. When confronted with CDC recommendations for widespread mask-wearing, Trump retorted, "I don't agree with the statement that if everyone wore a mask, everything disappears."

It is frustrating to see a leader dismiss empirical data. Studies indicate that masks can reduce individual risk by up to 65%, and universal mask-wearing could decrease transmission from asymptomatic individuals by nearly a third. The education system must prioritize critical thinking to prevent future leaders from undermining public health.

Trump’s claims that "masks cause problems too" merely fuel conspiracy theories among those who believe Covid is a hoax and masks are tools of control. His rationale for not imposing a nationwide mask mandate—"I want people to have a certain freedom"—is hypocritical coming from someone who escalates protests through police force.

Meanwhile, Adams attempts to convince a Fox News audience that science and personal freedom are not mutually exclusive. "We're not trying to take away your freedoms when we say wear a face covering," he insisted. "By following these guidelines, we can safely reopen schools and businesses."

Despite his hopeful outlook, it is clear that this crisis cannot be resolved solely by individual actions. It is disheartening to witness those who, despite knowing that masks can mitigate the spread of the virus, still refuse to comply. This includes individuals who trivialize mask-wearing and those who continue to gather in large groups.

The core of the issue lies with Donald Trump, whose reluctance to wear a mask set a poor example. Reports indicate that Trump was worried wearing a mask might project weakness or make him appear "ridiculous." His focus on reopening the economy, while downplaying the health crisis, has resulted in needless deaths.

Even someone with limited intellect should grasp the importance of masks in a public health emergency. Yet, Trump insists on disregarding medical advice, believing the crisis will resolve itself over time.

Republican governors, such as Greg Abbott of Texas and Brian Kemp of Georgia, have followed Trump's lead, resulting in dire consequences for their constituents, particularly among Black and Brown populations who are disproportionately affected. Local leaders have expressed frustration at being undermined by a president whose influence is far-reaching.

Adams may encounter similar resistance from Trump's loyal audience on Fox News, especially as the administration seeks to cut funding for testing and contact tracing. The message is clear: the government is indifferent to the pandemic's toll.

In contrast, countries like France have mandated masks in enclosed public spaces, showcasing a commitment to public health that is lacking in the U.S.

We should not be reliving the same debates over mask-wearing that plagued the Spanish flu pandemic a century ago. We had the opportunity to handle this crisis more effectively. Trump could have championed mask-wearing as a way to ensure public safety while securing his reelection. However, by the time he donned a mask, the damage was already done.

The protests against masks reflect a deeper issue, not the root cause. The devastation witnessed in New York during the spring should have served as a wake-up call. The responsibility falls squarely on Donald Trump, whose negligence has resulted in countless deaths. His recent attempt to wear a mask does not change this reality, especially as he continues to spread misinformation.

If Americans unite and wear masks, it will not be due to presidential leadership but rather a collective embrace of science over ideology. This is a fundamental truth we must rely on—I can only hope it remains so.

The first video, "Americans Hate Wearing Masks — It's A Century-Old Public Health Problem | NBC News," explores the long-standing issues surrounding mask-wearing in American culture, highlighting the intersection of public health and personal beliefs.

The second video, "Pranks Destroy Scam Callers- GlitterBomb Payback - YouTube," provides a humorous take on confronting unwanted callers, showcasing creativity in dealing with annoyances.