Chapter 1: The Struggles of Stephanie Land

In what could be dubbed "Stephanie Land's Sophomore Slump," or perhaps "Maid 2: From Neat Memoir to Messy Sequel," her new book Class reveals the challenges she faced following the success of her memoir Maid, which chronicled her experience as a single mother working as a housecleaner for $9 an hour in the Pacific Northwest. The story of her struggles resonates with many, but Class has faced a different reception, earning a lower grade compared to her previous work.

Despite receiving some positive reviews and being selected for the Good Morning America Book Club, Class has not fully recovered from its rocky start. Land shared with the Washington Post that she signed a contract in early 2020 for a narrative nonfiction book inspired by her life’s hardships. However, after the Netflix adaptation of Maid debuted in fall 2021, she faced significant writing challenges. "I'm not a journalist — I don't even know the code of ethics for all of that — so it was this really intimidating thing," she stated. She felt so blocked that she nearly informed her editor she could not proceed with the book.

The video titled "How to Write a Book in Microsoft Word [Tutorial]" provides insights that might resonate with aspiring authors facing similar hurdles.

Chapter 2: A Difficult Journey

Land ultimately switched publishers, and the immense popularity of the Maid miniseries allowed her the creative freedom to deviate from her original sequel plan. She decided to focus on her challenging senior year in college, describing it as "probably the hardest year of my life."

More than a decade earlier, Land had relocated from the Pacific Northwest to Montana for two primary reasons: to distance her daughter from her father, whom she considered a negative influence, and to pursue her dream of becoming a writer through a creative writing program at the University of Montana in Missoula.

In Class, Land chronicles her journey to earn a bachelor's degree in English in her mid-30s, detailing her struggle to pay over $50,000 for her education through a mix of loans, grants, food stamps, and part-time work as a maid. Amidst these challenges, she experienced an abortion and later became pregnant with her second daughter, who was born shortly after her graduation in 2014. Throughout this period, she faced hunger, panic attacks, severe scoliosis, PTSD, and child support disputes. The harsh Montana winters, where temperatures could drop to -30°F, further complicated her life, as she often relied on space heaters to keep her apartment warm.

Chapter 3: Financial Struggles and Systemic Challenges

While Land's story evokes sympathy for her struggles, the manner in which she narrates her experiences raises questions about credibility. In her author's note, she mentions that she has altered names and details, "compressed" timelines, and "approximated" dialogue. Although these techniques are acceptable in creative nonfiction, they must be executed with care.

Some of her anecdotes lack believability. For instance, she recalls a specific moment with a faculty adviser, detailing an instance where the professor picked fuzz off her slacks. Such precise recollections can feel contrived and detract from the narrative's authenticity. Additionally, her writing style sometimes appears cumbersome, relying too heavily on clichéd expressions.

One of the most compelling aspects of Class is Land's portrayal of her financial struggles, particularly the Kafkaesque hurdles she faced in obtaining government benefits for the working poor. She shares her frustrations when her food stamp benefits were cut once her daughter turned six, underlining the systemic issues that often exacerbate poverty.

At times, she found herself with only $10 left in her bank account at the end of the month, relying primarily on peanut butter for sustenance. "Long-term financial planning is for people who aren't living in poverty," she writes, emphasizing her focus on immediate needs over financial calculations.

Chapter 4: A Complicated Legacy

Land aspired to pursue a Master of Fine Arts degree, but her application was ultimately rejected. She firmly believes that her pregnancy with her second child played a role in this setback. While this may reflect the reality of sexism in academia, it also raises questions about her portrayal of the faculty member who had previously supported her. The contradiction in her acknowledgment of this professor's guidance in her earlier work suggests a lack of self-awareness regarding the complexities of these relationships.

The rejection she faced may have stemmed not only from gender bias but also from the possibility that she was competing against stronger candidates. The disparity in writing quality between Maid and Class could indicate that her new publisher did not maintain the same rigorous standards, or perhaps that the rush to publish was driven by the success of the Netflix series.

In conclusion, while Land's experiences shed light on the financial burdens faced by many college graduates, the execution of her narrative raises important questions about storytelling ethics and the authenticity of personal accounts.