Navigating the Digital Gaze: Power Dynamics on Social Media
Written on
Chapter 1: The Allure of Social Media
Social media provides unprecedented access to a global audience, creating a tempting opportunity for many. Numerous individuals now depend on these platforms for their livelihoods by sharing personal content, with some achieving remarkable financial success.
How many of us have contemplated the idea of posting a carefully curated photograph or an insightful video, hoping to cultivate a following from consistent engagement? Even if our goals are not monetary and simply involve carving out a presence online, we face the same critical questions: How much of ourselves should we reveal? What does it mean to present our lives as content? Do we genuinely desire to be seen? And what distinguishes our authentic selves from our online personas?
As an art writer, I have long been intrigued by the intricacies of observation and being observed. I believe that art history, particularly the concept of the "gaze," can help unpack these inquiries while highlighting some potential dangers of oversharing.
Section 1.1: Understanding the Gaze
The theory of the gaze involves one individual looking at another or a group observing another group. Many are familiar with the term "male gaze," introduced by film theorist Laura Mulvey, who asserted that film perspectives often reflect a heterosexual male viewpoint. This notion connects to the formation of gender and sexual differences, and it has also been applied to the portrayal of marginalized groups.
In any visual medium—be it photography, art, or film—engaging in observation asserts a claim to entitlement. If the gaze is unidirectional, it implies a power imbalance, where one individual dominates another. In essence, the theory of the gaze concerns the control of representation. In the context of social media, we can appropriately discuss the "digital gaze."
Section 1.2: The Transformation of Observation
Our methods of viewing and relating to others have been fundamentally altered by social media. With screens in our palms, we perceive the world through a private lens. Like the introduction of perspective in art, social media feeds are tailored to make us the ideal observers—each person experiences a unique feed designed specifically for them.
Additionally, engagement often occurs passively. As algorithms curate an endless stream of updates, each interaction we have refines our digital environment, enhancing our sense of agency. However, this gratification comes with a dark side, as we navigate the tension between wanting to be seen and the desire to observe ourselves being observed.
The theory of the gaze warns us that looking conventions can normalize power disparities. In the realm of social media, however, the question arises: who wields the power?
Chapter 2: The Competition of Social Media
The competitive nature of social media elicits both doubt and pleasure. We often perceive others as more successful, with larger followings and more engagement, making their achievements seem effortlessly attained.
To thrive on social media, one must cultivate an awareness of the audience. The ultimate reward is attention. This competition encourages us to showcase our experiences, opinions, and preferences, as each interaction represents a small share of the capital that social media appears to distribute.
In today's landscape, personal narratives are ubiquitous, with the means of representation readily available. Social media serves as both a platform for existential expression and a complex arena for self-promotion. These elements intertwine so closely that personal experiences become a form of self-valuation. Many individuals commodify their lives, seeking validation while often prioritizing their "brand" over reality.
Lowering your gaze on social media explores the implications of our digital interactions and the importance of mindful engagement.
Subsection 2.1: The Dynamics of Judgment
We create representations of our experiences and willingly exchange this content with others. This practice has become integral to our personal and professional lives. With smartphones at hand and social media platforms accessible without barriers, we all possess the power to influence narratives.
However, our contributions can be repurposed by others, integrating us into their stories without our consent. Consequently, the boundary between the observer and the observed becomes blurred, leading to uncertainty about who holds the power.
Through social media, we engage in mutual observation and judgment, accepting assessments made of us while also participating as judges. This creates a reciprocal relationship, where we watch ourselves being watched, ceding power to an abstract audience rather than a specific individual or group.
The normalization of discrepancies between our online and offline identities further complicates this dynamic. As we present curated online personas, the gap between our realities and our digital representations expands.
The Male Gaze on Social Media delves into the implications of gendered perspectives and the power dynamics at play in our online interactions.
Chapter 3: The Nature of Digital Dialogue
Dialogue within social media is often superficial. Unlike traditional communication—like letters or phone calls—that assumes mutual agreement, social media content is generally free-floating, lacking a structured context for interaction. Conversations emerge and dissipate, and relationships can flourish or fade without warning.
Content typically begins with a declaration: an opinion shared, a meal photographed, or a travel experience documented, all conveying the underlying message, "I have lived this." The nature of social media resembles advertising more than genuine dialogue, as messages are broadcasted in hopes of capturing the audience's attention.
Section 3.1: The Illusion of Sharing
John Berger articulated how advertising thrives on the envy we feel toward unattainable products, which we then hope to flip into envy from others by possessing those products. He asserts that "being envied is a solitary form of reassurance." To "share" on social media is not to relinquish ownership but to assert it.
The shift in the meaning of "sharing" since Berger's time is striking. Today, sharing experiences is about informing others rather than dividing ownership. This changes our perspective on observation: we position ourselves as the ultimate controllers of the narrative while unconsciously curating our representations to elicit positive judgments.
Social media thrives on the perception of granting access to our lives, yet we often disconnect from our realities, distorting time to align with the expectations of our audience.
Chapter 4: The Duality of Power
The experience of "speaking into a void" is common among those who receive little feedback on social media. The longing for validation intensifies feelings of invisibility, particularly when we perceive others gaining larger audiences.
The power dynamics continually shift, creating psychological tension. At times we feel empowered, while at others we feel subjugated to the whims of the audience. Our standing among peers is perpetually in flux, influenced by this cycle of affirmation and doubt.
Section 4.1: Looking Ahead
Reversing our path of digital interconnectedness seems nearly impossible. We are compelled to adapt and engage more deeply with technology. For many, our livelihoods hinge on digital literacy, particularly in social media, which also plays a critical role in maintaining relationships.
The rapid pace of change is concerning, yet we embrace new technologies with enthusiasm. As we ponder the future, we must contemplate strategies to shield ourselves from the psychological effects of the digital gaze.
While we navigate the vast sea of images and words, we may find ourselves in positions of perceived superiority, casting judgment while simultaneously relinquishing power by inviting scrutiny. We observe ourselves being observed, which carries inherent value, yet we must be wary of the implications.
As the French proverb states, "He who can lick can bite."
Christopher P Jones, author of "Great Paintings Explained," offers a deep dive into the narratives of art. Would you like to receive…
A free guide to the Essential Styles in Western Art History, along with updates and exclusive news about my work? Download it for free here. Connect with me…
On Instagram for more insights into art and culture!