Exploring Whoop Again: A Three-Month Journey in 2024
Written on
Chapter 1: The Comeback of Whoop
In 2022, I tested the Whoop band for a three-month period, but ultimately, it didn't become a staple for me. This review came about after Whoop reached out, inviting me to cover their popular yet niche fitness device. Prior to this, I hadn’t considered adding Whoop to my health and fitness routine, as I had been firmly in the Apple Watch Ultra camp. However, my recent experiences with the Garmin MARQ Commander and other Garmin models made me realize that I might be ready to move on from Apple’s ecosystem entirely.
Whoop is a different beast altogether; it’s not a watch and lacks any ecosystem. It’s also more expensive than the Apple Watch when you factor in the annual subscription fee. So, what prompted me to make a Whoop band and a year-long subscription my first tech investment of 2024? Let me explain.
Section 1.1: My Initial Experience with Whoop
At the conclusion of my initial three-month review, I recognized that while Whoop is an excellent device for a specific demographic, it wasn’t right for me. The abundance of health and fitness metrics available through the Whoop app was both impressive and daunting. Much like Garmin's Connect app, the data can be overwhelming. I know there are enthusiasts who dissect every metric, but much of it feels like a foreign language to me.
Heart Rate Variability (HRV), sleep debt, and respiratory rates, along with intricate graphs, almost immediately deterred me from continuing with Whoop. If you know me, you understand that I typically operate at a basic functional level with most gadgets. I’m the epitome of a "normal" user, and my reviews reflect that perspective. The complexity of Whoop felt like an uphill battle, although I could see its appeal to dedicated athletes.
Another reason I chose not to extend my Whoop trial was that I misplaced the charger. I’ve taken some ribbing about this (rightfully so) in the comments of my video, but I maintain that the requirement to charge the Whoop via a "puck" is impractical—it's just too easy to misplace. For the record, I did find it a couple of months later.
Section 1.2: What Made Me Return to Whoop
On December 27, I made the decision to purchase a Whoop subscription—nearly a year after my initial experience with the band. I was fortunate to catch a holiday promotion that reduced the subscription cost by about £30, bringing my total to £198.33 (the band is included at no additional cost). This translates to roughly £16.53 per month, which feels reasonable, especially considering it’s a fraction of my gym membership. If I play my cards right, this could yield significant health and fitness benefits.
Two primary factors influenced my decision to return to Whoop. First, I worry that I might be over-training or not exercising at optimal times. I consistently hit the gym, and over the years, it has become an essential part of my routine. However, I lack expertise in maximizing my workouts. I know my body may either be ready for exercise or in need of rest, and misjudging this can have negative consequences.
Second, my sleep habits are poor. I identify as a "night owl," a poor excuse for my late nights and grumpy mornings. Anyone over 40 knows the importance of considering how your lifestyle choices affect your longevity. As I hear more from experts about sleep, I realize how detrimental my current habits are.
Whoop focuses on three critical metrics: sleep, recovery, and strain. These metrics are interconnected, and understanding how your behaviors affect them is crucial for optimal health. The principle is straightforward: achieve sufficient quality sleep, and your body will recover effectively. If recovery is successful, you can handle more strain, which is essential for heart health. Skimp on sleep, and recovery falters, leaving you unprepared for physical exertion.
While there’s much more to Whoop, my goal this year is to enhance my sleep quality, and I believe Whoop could be the tool I need.
Chapter 2: Initial Reflections After Three Months of Whoop
I was mistaken—the Whoop charging system is quite ingenious. The band is intended for continuous wear, providing the most accurate health and fitness readings. To avoid frequent charging, Whoop includes a waterproof battery pack that attaches to the band and charges it in about 2.5 hours, offering four to five days of use. This feature is both convenient and innovative, making it user-friendly—unless you’re like me and misplace it.
The band is generally comfortable, though I’m not a fan of its aesthetic. The Whoop 4.0 resembles the wristbands given at nightclubs more than a sleek fitness tracker. While you can customize the bands with different colors, I often wish it were a bit smaller. Comfort can be an issue, especially in warmer weather; those who struggle with watch discomfort may find the Whoop band less than ideal.
Regarding metrics, there’s a vast amount of data, much of which I don't fully grasp. However, I am beginning to understand my health better. I’ve learned what HRV means, grasped the concept of sleep debt, and recognized how sleep, recovery, and strain are interconnected.
The new Whoop Coach has been incredibly helpful in this regard. Created with the assistance of OpenAI, this AI-based coach helps users interpret the data in the Whoop app and offers tailored workout advice based on personal health data. This feature was absent during my initial trial.
Whoop also prompts you to reconsider the effects of alcohol consumption. To put it bluntly, the benefits are minimal. I’ve heard stories of users who abandoned Whoop due to its constant reminders of how alcohol impacts recovery. The effects of even a single glass of wine on recovery can be staggering.
Ultimately, my key takeaway from the last three months with Whoop is that the responsibility lies with you to make the most of it. The band and app merely reveal how your body reacts to your daily choices. It’s up to you to utilize this data to improve your health. Anyone hoping for miraculous results without putting in the effort will likely be disappointed. My sleep is gradually improving, as is my readiness for workouts, but it remains a challenge, regardless of Whoop’s recommendations.
As I plan to keep the Whoop band on for the rest of the year, I’ll compare its performance against other wearables, including smartwatches and rings (more on that soon!).
Chapter 3: The Implications for the Apple Watch
I feel like I’m juggling two relationships at the moment. I genuinely appreciate the Apple Watch—particularly the extravagant, adventure-ready Apple Watch Ultra. I've worn Apple's device almost continuously since 2015. Yet, I’ve opened my mind to alternatives. The Garmin MARQ Commander has captivated me (mainly because of its 'Applied Ballistics' feature), and the return of the Whoop band has provided far more insight this time.
I haven’t abandoned the Apple Watch, I assure you. As a tech reviewer, I remain committed to the Apple ecosystem. However, this year is about expanding my horizons in fitness technology, and I eagerly anticipate where this journey will take me.
Before You Go
Join my newsletter for a weekly behind-the-scenes look at a tech content creator!
This video explores the long-term value of using Whoop after five years. Is it still worth it in 2024?
This video covers the latest updates for Whoop in 2024, revealing its new features and enhancements.