Racial Disparities in Maternal Health: Addressing the Crisis
Written on
Understanding Maternal Mortality Disparities
The health and welfare of mothers and infants should be a universal priority. However, America's history of systemic racism complicates this vital discussion. Black women face the highest rates of maternal mortality in the U.S., experiencing deaths at a rate four times greater than that of their White counterparts. This troubling reality underscores the heightened risks that Black women encounter during pregnancy. Even with the pressing need for reform, attempts to reduce maternal mortality through legislative measures often encounter strong resistance. This situation raises concerns about whether we can overcome these challenges or if we will continue to see tragic losses in the Black community.
A prominent instance of this opposition occurred in California, where state lawmakers on the Health Committee received a letter from white supremacist organizations vehemently opposing AB 2319, a proposed bill aimed at reducing maternal mortality. These groups made the racist assertion that "Every non-white birth in this state is a drain on taxpayers." Essentially, they recognize the high maternal mortality rates among Black women but dismiss legislation intended to save lives as a misuse of resources. This attitude reflects a broader disregard for Black lives, reminiscent of the widespread opposition to the Black Lives Matter movement, highlighting the persistent barriers our nation faces in addressing and alleviating racial disparities.
The Struggle for Legislative Change
Given the significant gap in maternal mortality rates between Black and White women, many may wonder if our nation can effectively address this issue. Fortunately, there is some encouraging news. Research by Howell (2018) indicates that a considerable number of severe maternal morbidity and mortality incidents are preventable. If healthcare providers adopt appropriate interventions, they can significantly reduce these rates. However, it is frustrating to see how America's healthcare system continues to perpetuate racial inequalities instead of embracing solutions informed by community needs and research. For example, Senator Cassidy pointed out that if Black women were excluded from Louisiana's maternal mortality statistics, the state wouldn't appear as an outlier.
In an effort to combat these disparities, the Black Maternal Health Momnibus Act, introduced by Senator Cory Booker, currently has 32 sponsors, all Democrats except for Independent Senator Bernie Sanders. The resistance to passing federal laws aimed at addressing maternal mortality predominantly stems from conservative factions. Although Republicans often proclaim their commitment to family values and the sanctity of life, their reluctance to support legislation designed to reduce Black maternal mortality reveals how racial biases influence their policy decisions.
The Political Landscape of Maternal Health
If White women experienced complications during childbirth at a rate four times greater than Black women, it is likely there would be substantial bipartisan support for related legislation. Conservatives often express a fixation on White birth rates, driven by anxieties about demographic shifts. This misplaced emphasis leads them to advocate for laws that limit women's reproductive rights while ignoring the dangers faced by Black women during childbirth. Consequently, Black women find themselves disproportionately affected by policies that were not designed with their welfare in mind. Howell (2018) also highlighted that a significant share of severe maternal morbidity and mortality cases are preventable. By providing expectant mothers with quality healthcare and educational resources, we can effectively address the racial disparities in maternal mortality. Yet, some White individuals maintain that investing in this issue is a waste of resources.
The harmful belief that non-white births represent a "drain" on taxpayer dollars parallels sentiments expressed by white supremacists advocating the "Great Replacement Theory." The actions of Payton Gendron, an 18-year-old white supremacist who targeted Black individuals in Buffalo, NY, in 2022, echoed this disturbing ideology, suggesting that to maintain a stable population, higher birth rates among White individuals are necessary.
The Root Causes of Racial Disparities
Why do racial disparities in maternal mortality continue to exist? Njoku et al. (2023) identify several structural determinants contributing to maternal mortality, including the historical legacy of slavery, structural racism, and institutional policies (such as Jim Crow laws, the GI Bill, and redlining), alongside social determinants like food insecurity, healthcare access, and income inequality. Black women are more likely to reside in under-resourced communities that lack access to preventive care and quality medical treatment, which further exacerbates the disparities in care received compared to White expectant mothers.
The ongoing resistance to legislation aimed at reducing maternal mortality stems from a fundamental lack of recognition of the value of Black lives. To ensure that Black women receive the protection and support they deserve, it is crucial to advocate for policies that allocate resources to address this urgent crisis. We must ensure that racist opposition does not overshadow the long-term goal of establishing a more equitable healthcare system.