Initial Findings

The journey began in the 1950s when Father Theodor Verhoeven, a Dutch priest with a passion for archaeology, resided on the small Indonesian island of Flores, located east of Java. While serving at a Catholic seminary, he excavated numerous archaeological sites, unearthing a wealth of Neolithic burials and artifacts.

Liang Bua Cave

Excavations continue at some of Verhoeven’s sites, particularly at Liang Bua cave, which has been a source of significant discoveries over the years. In 2003, a team led by palaeoanthropologist Peter Brown from the University of New England, Australia, discovered a nearly complete, previously unidentified hominin skeleton within the cave. Analysis revealed that the remains belonged to an adult female who lived between 50,000 and 90,000 years ago and stood at just over three and a half feet tall.

This individual was not a Homo sapiens, but rather a newly recognized hominin species, named Homo floresiensis, after the island where the remains were found. Due to their diminutive stature, these hominins have been affectionately referred to as "hobbits," reminiscent of characters from J.R.R. Tolkien's literary works.

Mata Menge Discovery

In 2016, paleoanthropologist Yousuke Kaifu from the University of Tokyo and his team made an additional discovery east of Liang Bua cave in the So'a Basin, an area that was once a riverbed. They uncovered six small teeth, parts of a skull, and a jawbone, all seemingly belonging to a diminutive hominin. Remarkably, dating indicated these remains were around 700,000 years old, significantly older than those found at Liang Bua cave.

The considerable age gap between the two sites raises intriguing questions: Could these fossils represent the same species, albeit separated by eons? However, the fragmentary nature of the remains has left researchers unable to definitively connect them to the Liang Bua population or identify them as a distinct species.

Newest Developments

Kaifu and his colleagues—Adam Brumm, an Archaeology Professor at Griffith University, and Gerrit van den Bergh, a paleontology researcher—shared their latest findings in a publication by The Conversation. They revealed that three years before their 2016 study, they had discovered tiny limb bone fragments during their excavations at Mata Menge. Initially misidentified as belonging to a reptile, the curator at the Geology Museum in Bandung, Indra Sutisna, later recognized the fragment as a human upper arm bone. This was subsequently confirmed by Kaifu, who initially believed it belonged to a child due to its small size.

Despite the incomplete nature of the humerus, it is the smallest adult arm bone documented in the human fossil record. The researchers were able to estimate the height of the individual it belonged to, concluding that the Mata Menge hominin likely stood between 3 feet and 3 feet 9 inches tall, with the best estimate being around 3 feet 2 inches—three inches shorter than the Liang Bua hominins.

Remaining Questions

While it appears logical to assume that the Liang Bua hominins evolved from the smaller Mata Menge relatives, the situation is more complicated upon deeper examination. Some experts propose that both groups descended from Homo habilis, a small species found solely in Africa. However, the geographical disconnect presents challenges for this hypothesis.

Most researchers, including Kaifu and his colleagues, lean towards the idea that both hominin populations are descendants of Homo erectus, a species that thrived from approximately 1.89 million to 110,000 years ago, making it the longest-living hominin species. Evidence suggests that H. erectus was the first hominin to leave Africa and inhabit regions like Java, close to Flores.

Yet, no H. erectus remains have been discovered on Flores itself, adding complexity to the narrative. The researchers note that the arm bone's characteristics do not align perfectly with those of H. erectus, resembling instead smaller-bodied species like H. floresiensis and H. naledi.

Even so, their article highlights that the Liang Bua hominins exhibit unique evolutionary traits, hinting at a possible ancestry linked to H. erectus. Another possibility is that these characteristics developed independently during their isolation on the island. Ultimately, they conclude that the fossils from Mata Menge lend support to the notion that a group of early Asian H. erectus evolved into H. floresiensis after becoming isolated on Flores.

The significant question remains: how did these diminutive hominins evolve from a larger ancestor? Evolution may provide insights, as species can adapt dramatically in size when isolated—either shrinking or growing depending on environmental pressures.

Kaifu explained that the absence of large predators on Flores may have allowed smaller body sizes to thrive, as these require fewer resources for sustenance and reproduction. He posits that over a span of 300,000 years, descendants likely evolved into smaller forms, maintaining this trait for extended periods.

However, this does not clarify why Liang Bua hominins grew taller than their predecessors. These unresolved issues add to the intrigue surrounding their evolutionary path.

How Did They Reach Flores?

Regardless of their lineage, the question of how these Hobbit hominins found themselves on Flores remains unanswered. Archaeological evidence does not support the idea that they constructed rafts or boats for their journey. It is plausible that they were marooned on the island following some unforeseen event.

Gerrit van den Bergh suggested that the arrival of the original hominin species on Flores could have been a chance occurrence, though the specifics remain elusive. Ongoing excavations might uncover more fossils that could bridge the 650,000-year gap in our understanding of their evolutionary journey.

The Fate of the Hobbits

The final query is about the eventual fate of the H. floresiensis population. Evidence indicates that they inhabited Flores for several hundred thousand years, but their extinction occurred relatively recently, estimated between 50,000 to 12,000 years ago. This timeline overlaps with the migrations of our Homo sapiens ancestors from Africa, raising questions about potential interactions—or conflict—between the two species.

While it is possible that our ancestors contributed to their extinction, the precise cause remains a mystery that future research may help clarify.

A Broader Perspective

The complexities surrounding the evolution of these hominins, particularly how a species ended up isolated on an Indonesian island, are fascinating. Indonesia's unique geography, situated between the Pacific and Indian Oceans and across two continental shelves, may have played a role in shaping the evolutionary paths of its ancient inhabitants.

The region's numerous islands, diverse landscapes, and geological activity may have contributed to the isolation of H. erectus, leading to the emergence of H. floresiensis. As scientists continue to explore these questions, we are reminded of the vast unknowns that still exist in our understanding of human evolution.

This article was initially featured in my newsletter, Curious Adventure, which highlights remarkable scientific discoveries across various fields, emphasizing the extent of our ignorance about the past.

Thank you for reading. Your interest is greatly appreciated.

Discover how recent findings reveal the origins of our Hobbit cousins, shedding light on their evolutionary journey.

Delve into the fascinating story of Homo floresiensis, the real-life Hobbit, in this documentary that explores prehistoric humans.